Comparative Analysis of Islamic and Conventional Mutual Funds’ Performance during Financial Crisis and Non-crisis Periods in Pakistan

  • Imran Ahmed University of Karachi
  • Danish Ahmed Siddiqui University of Karachi

Abstract

This study aims to analyze and investigates the differences in performance of Islamic and conventional mutual funds in three periods, namely the period during the financial crisis period, dated 2008 to 2009, after crises period 2010 to 2017, and the whole period, dated from 2007 to 2017. More specifically the study aims to investigate whether the Shariah compliant Equity, Income and Assets Allocation Mutual funds performed better in terms of risk adjusted basis as compared to the conventional Equity, Income and asset allocation mutual funds. The risk return behaviors were examined by employing performance measures such as Sharpe, Treynor, and Jensen Alpha. Moreover, their performance in coping of systematic risk is also analyzed by regressing macroeconomic variables on returns. Study concluded that Conventional Income mutual funds perform better in all three periods including (crises and non-crises) compare to its counterpart Islamic income mutual funds in both risks adjusted basis and simple arithmetic mean basis, however their difference is not statistically significant. Study also found that Islamic equity mutual funds perform better in crises period as compare to its conventional equity mutual funds in risk adjusted basis In crises period both funds gave negative return, but Islamic equity mutual funds declined less than conventional mutual funds which shows that Islamic mutual funds provide better hedging in crises period., however there were no significant difference among the two in the other two periods. Similarly, Assets Allocation funds also have no significant difference among themselves, however Islamic asset allocation mutual funds outperform conventional asset allocation mutual funds in all three periods, especially in crises period where Islamic funds showing positive returns as compared to conventional fund that were suffering in loss of about 14%. Overall the whole period performance of Islamic mutual funds is slightly better but not statically difference.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Imran Ahmed, University of Karachi

Research Scholar, Karachi University Business School, University of Karachi, Karachi, PAKISTAN

Danish Ahmed Siddiqui, University of Karachi

Associate Professor, Karachi University Business School, University of Karachi, Karachi, PAKISTAN

References

Abderrezak, F. (2008). The performance of Islamic equity funds: A comparison to conventional. Islamic and ethical benchmarks, Retrieved April 1: 2010.

Banani, A. and Hidayatun, N. A. (2017). Performance of Islamic indices: risk adjusted returns of shariah compliant stocks on Jakarta Islamic index and Dow Jones Islamic turkey. Journal of Economics & Business, Vol. 01, No. 01 (April-2017) 001-018.

Beck, T., A. Demirgüç-Kunt and O. Merrouche, (2013). Islamic Vs. Conventional Banking: Business Model, Efficiency and Stability. Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 37, 433-447.

Bilal Nafees, Muhammad Ali Jibran Qamar, Nisar Ahmad (2018). Lucrativeness of Islamic vs conventional mutual funds in Pakistan. Pakistan Business Review Jan 2018. JEL Calcification: G 230.

Dharani, M. and Natarajan, P. (2011). Seasonal Anomalies between S&P CNX Nifty Shariah Index and S&P CNX Nifty Index in India. Journal of Social and Development Sciences. Vol. 1, No. 3, 101-108.

Elfakhani, S., Hasan, M. K., & Sidani, Y. (2005). Comparative performance of Islamic versus secular mutual funds. Paper presented at the 12th Economic Research Forum, University of New Orleans, US.

Fikriyah Abdullah, Taufiq Hassan, Shamsher Mohamad (2007). Investigation of performance of Malaysian Islamic unit trust funds: Comparison with conventional unit trust funds. Managerial Finance, 33(2): 142-153.

Hayat, R. and R. Kraeussl (2011). Risk and return characteristics of Islamic equity funds. Emerging Markets Review, 12(2): 189-203.

Hesham Merdad, M. Kabir Hassan and Yasser Alhenawi (2010). Islamic Versus Conventional Mutual Funds Performance in Saudi Arabia: A Case Study. JKAU: Islamic Econ., Vol. 23 No. 2, 157-193.

Hoepner, A. G. F. & Mcmillan, D. G. (2009). Responsible Investment: An Influential Literature Analysis comprising a rating, characterization, categorization & investigation. Available: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1454793 [Accessed 2017, September 6].

Hussein, K. (2005). Islamic investment: Evidence from Dow Jones and FTSE

Hussein, K. and Omran, M. (2005). Ethical Investment revisited: Evidence from Dow Jones Islamic Indexes. The Journal of Investing. 105-124.

Issam BOUSALAM, Moustapha HAMZAOUI (2016). Impact of Ethical Screening on Risk and Returns: The Case of Constructed Moroccan Islamic Stock Indexes. MPRA Paper No. 68979, posted 23 January 2016 11:26 UTC.

Mohsina Habib, Khalid Ul Islam, (2014). An Empirical Assessment of Islamic Index: A Case Study of India. IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563, Vol.4, No.3.

Nasir Razzaq, Sajid Gul1, Muhammad Sajid, Sumra Mughal, Syeda Asma Bukhari, (2012). Performance of Islamic Mutual Funds in Pakistan. Economics and Finance Review, Vol. 2(3) pp. 16, ISSN: 2047 – 0401.

Osamah M. Al-Khazali, Guillaume Leduc, Mohammad Saleh Alsayed (2015). A Market Efficiency Comparison of Islamic and Non-Islamic Stock Indices. Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, Volume 52, Pages 1587-1605.

Saud Ahmed Khan, Muhammad Khaleequzzaman, Muhammad Ishfaq, Shahan Zeb Khan (2017). Comparative Risk and Return Analysis of Islamic and Conventional Financial Institutions in Pakistan. International journal of Islamic economics and finance studies, Vol: 3, Issue: 1, p-ISSN: 2149-8407.

Sejarah, A. (2015). How performance of Jakarta Islamic index (JII) stocks relative to other stocks?.Jurnal Dinamika Manajemen, JDM Vol. 6, No. 2, 2015, 145-164.

Shaliza Alwi, Rosimah Ahmad, Irma Zura Amir Hashim, Norbaizura Mohd Naim (2017). Investigating the Islamic and Conventional Mutual Fund Performance: Evidence from Malaysia Equity Market. International Conference on Management and Information Systems.

Statman, M. (2000). Socially responsible mutual funds. Financial Analysts Journal. Vol 56 (3), 30–39.

Yacine Hammami, Abdel monem Oueslati (2017). Measuring skill in the Islamic mutual fund industry: Evidence from GCC countries. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, Volume 49, Pages 15-31.

Zia-ur-Rehman Rao, Muhammad Zubair Tauni, Amjad Iqbal, (2015). Comparison between Islamic and general Equity Funds of Pakistan: Difference in their performances and Fund Flow Volatility. Emerging Economy Studies. Vol 1(2) 211-226.

--0--

Published
2018-12-15
How to Cite
Ahmed, I. and Siddiqui, D. A. (2018) “Comparative Analysis of Islamic and Conventional Mutual Funds’ Performance during Financial Crisis and Non-crisis Periods in Pakistan”, Global Disclosure of Economics and Business, 7(2), pp. 63-80. Available at: http://i-proclaim.my/archive/index.php/gdeb/article/view/537 (Accessed: 14October2019).
Section
Articles